Spend enough time listening to the current administration in Washington and you might come away believing Europe has one foot in the grave and the other sliding toward irrelevance. The story is familiar by now. The United States is strong. Europe is weak. The United States is vigorous. Europe is in decline. And the European Union, that sprawling project of integration and compromise, is painted as little more than an exhausted bureaucracy staggering toward collapse.

It is an effective political story. It is not an accurate economic one.

What the data show is far more nuanced. The United States is indeed outpacing Europe on headline growth. That part is real. Quarter after quarter, American GDP numbers look stronger. In one recent comparison the US economy grew eight times faster than the eurozone, which managed a tenth of a percent while the United States beat that figure with ease. This difference is not an illusion created by currency shifts or accounting tricks. It reflects higher productivity growth in the United States, stronger investment, and a demographic profile that remains more favourable than Europe’s. These are material advantages and they reveal real structural gaps.

Yet to jump from those facts to grand claims about European “civilizational decline” is to turn analysis into theatre. The United States is growing more quickly, but the European Union is still one of the largest and most advanced economic regions on the planet. Its labour markets remain stable. Inflation is drifting toward target levels. Living standards across much of Europe remain globally competitive and, in many sectors, outperform American norms once cost and purchasing power are accounted for. A slower growth profile does not equal economic illness. It equals a different model with different strengths and different vulnerabilities.

Why then the drama. Because it serves a purpose. The administration’s own national security strategy now speaks of Europe as a continent on the verge of losing itself, a place where current trends will render the region unrecognizable in twenty years. It warns that internal EU policies are eroding sovereignty and liberty and it openly states an intention to cultivate political resistance inside European nations. Such language is not a neutral economic assessment. It is political positioning wrapped in the clothing of economic diagnosis.

And that positioning does not fall on deaf ears. Nationalist movements in Europe hear the signal clearly. Parties like the AfD in Germany have seized on Washington’s rhetoric as validation and have used it to bolster their own claims about a European project supposedly in decay. The administration’s framing becomes a feedback loop. A strong America. A weak Europe. A proud nationalist revival sweeping the continent. It is a narrative that simplifies complex economic realities for political advantage on both sides of the Atlantic.

The truth sits somewhere far less dramatic. Europe is not collapsing. It is not unravelling. It is navigating a period of slow growth, productivity challenges, and regulatory debates that are real but hardly apocalyptic. The gaps between the EU and the United States are partly economic and partly structural, but the story of a dying Europe is a rhetorical construction, not an economic fact.

That story will continue to circulate because it is useful. It creates a contrast that flatters American power. It energises nationalist movements in Europe that reject Brussels and prefer bilateral dealings with Washington. And it gives political actors in the United States an external example to point toward when arguing that their own model is not only stronger but morally superior.

Economic data rarely shout. They whisper. And what they whisper today is simple. Europe is slower than the United States, yes. Europe is wrestling with productivity and demographic pressures, yes. But Europe is not on the brink. The rhetoric is doing the heavy lifting, not the numbers.

Sources:
euronews.com
courthousenews.com
economy-finance.ec.europa.eu
reuters.com
theguardian.com